How to Meet Crazy Outhouse Girl in Red Dead Redemption 2 ?

Step 1

First, you will need to go to this place Southwest of Rhodes.

Step 2

After getting there, head west towards an Outhouse.

Step 3

You will notice that few voices are coming out of the Outhouse.

Step 4

Get off your horse and listen to her.

Step 5

Her dialog is limited, it will end afterwards.

Step 6

Arthur is in Lantern and gun trick mode.

Step 7

You have to use this trick to go inside later.

Step 8

Just stand there and keep listening for clues on who she is.

Step 9

She sometimes touch the walls.

Step 10

You will find that she has been inside for most of her life.

Step 11

And she knows a person named Penelope.

Step 12

You need to bring Penelope here later.

Step 13

And keep listening to this good voice acting.

Step 14

She will spit but this is a rare event.

Step  15

Just stand there and listen to all her ramblings, No repeats.

Step 16

That is the end of all her dialogs.

Step 17

She will do a grab animation if you peek.

Step 18

After peeking, she will start saying the numbers.

Step 19

The next thing you need to do is inspect to get the journal entry.

Step 20

Bring a gun out of your inventory and fire straight up in the air. Then she will say the final numbers.

Step 21

8 9 3.. 1 2 3 4 1 2 1

Step 22

After that, she will become silent.

Step 23

Now, you have to use your lantern and gun trick to get inside.

Step 24

When you face her, she will start screaming.

Step 25

And then she says the same final numbers.

Step 26

Now you are inside the outhouse with her.

Step 27

She doesn’t move if you bump into her.

Step 28

And she doesn’t talk or move afterwards.

Step 29

If you try to scare her with your guns, she won’t.

Step 30

And also, you can’t lasso her.

Step 31

She is immune to dynamite.

Step 32

And she is also immune fire bottle.

Step 33

You can’t tackle or harm her in any way.

Step 34

After that, you will need to look for Penelope’s letter.

Step 35

Penelope Braithwaite is girl mentioned.

Step 36

Now you need to meet Penelope Braithwaite nearby.

Step 37

Ride Penelope on your horse but don’t go to train.

Step 38

Take her to outhouse (clues revealed).

Step 39

You will find that they are cousins so her name is Gertrude.

Step 40

Leaving triggers the final talk about her.

Step 41

Now you have to get Catherine Braithwaite’s Brooch.

Step 42

Then help Penelope and Beau go to the destination.

Step 43

Get them to stagecoach and take the reward.

Step 44

Now you will need to compare prices of both jewelry at fence.

Step 45

$75 (Penelope) versus $25 (Catherine).