This guide will let you know where to find the Alligators in the New World.
When you go to the first light on the bottom right side of the map, you can easily find the Alligators in the swampy area, as shown in the image below.
You can find the alligators from one section to another when you get there. And when you have Town board missions to kill alligators, this location is the best place to complete those missions.
You will need to head to the left side of the map, “First light” which is cutlass keys for the next location. It is designed for players who are around level 30.
When you get there, you will find a lot of alligators near the beach. Kill one of them, and you will find the next one very easily.